|
Post by snivydash on Aug 10, 2011 11:48:01 GMT -5
Rate the 8 movies here.
PS - 8/10 - Really good. CoS - 7/10 - Dragged it on too much. PoA - 8/10 - Same as PS. GoF - 9/10 - Loved it. Cedric was brilliant. Voldemort was scary too. OoTP - 9/10 - Same as GoF minus Cedric but plus for Sirius. HBP - 9/10 - A mix of everything. Great climax. DH1 - 9/10 - More than your average camping trip. DH2 - 10/10 - Harry and friends return to Hogwarts for the final battle, having gotten Hufflepuff's Cup from Gringotts.
|
|
WolfDawn185
First Year
WolfDawn185 - Just call me Wolf.
Posts: 82
|
Post by WolfDawn185 on Aug 11, 2011 8:28:33 GMT -5
I'll try this... I'm not gonna give them /10 ratings, though, I'm giving them /8 (my favs in order, in other words. 1/8 is top): SS: 5/8. Not the best, but it's the first. Bonus point for that. But I have to admit, Hagrid knocking down the door was awesome. CoS: 8/8. Slow plot, the basilisk scene in some places was quite cheesy. PoA: 2/8. The werewolf scene is fantastic. We also get the first hints of Ron/Hermione things to come. GoF: 3/8. First time we see Ralph Fiennes, and he was awesome in his one scene. OotP: 6/8. Some of the scenes that were, quite frankly, classics (brain room, anyone?) were cut. Sirius' death wasn't quite as dramatic. HBP: 4/8. Dumbledore's death. 'Nuff said. DH1: 7/8. At some points it just seemed like 3 teenagers camping out away from civilization screaming at each other. Also, the plot was slow. Yes, go ahead, give me criticism. I just didn't like the way this one turned out. DH2: 1/8. It's the best part of the series, and I like the way this one turned out.
|
|
Naoko
Magical
CatMirror2. 'Nuf said.
Posts: 25
|
Post by Naoko on Aug 12, 2011 4:56:43 GMT -5
Whoa, Snivy, you sure were generous with your points I tend to rate films by how much/how little they left off, so you can already tell it's not gonna be pretty. But I haven't seen most of them in awhile, so the rating will probably be better than it should really be. ^.^' Here goes... PS/SS - 9/10. Everything's good and pretty and happy an IN! Columbus gave a nice start... CoS - 8/10. Something felt off, but still. Even tho the director pretty much specialises in children films, he did do the justice to the books. And stuck to the plot PoA - 8/10. Cuaron is love. He really showed that the series was getting darker. GoF - 4/10. I honestly do not remember what ticked me off so much about this film, but I remember almost rage-quitting. In my head, that's enough of a reason to give it a 4. OoTP - 6/10. Down the road of important details being thrown away we go... Elloes, Mr. Yates. HBP - 7/10. Emo Draco, bitchy Harry and more little things being dumped. Surely, they will never come up again, right?... But this one DID have a lot of pretty moving pictures which bumped the rating way up DH1/2 - 9/10. I always regarded them as the same film. Yates has gotten significantly better at what he was doing and I was able to finally keep the raging fangirl at bay. They showed everything they could (I'm looking at you, Movies 4-5-6 >.>), and I loved the soundtrack. Doesn't take much to win me over Rant over!
|
|
borunks
Magical
GhostThestral57
Posts: 19
|
Post by borunks on Aug 12, 2011 23:27:49 GMT -5
wooahh u guys ripped on chamber of secrets, thats the one i watched the most since my babysitter didnt have cable i watched that like 15 times when i was a kid. I thought it was pretty good, at least an 8 out of 10
|
|
|
Post by snivydash on Aug 13, 2011 0:35:02 GMT -5
But I thought they did drag it on too long. The book was a bit pacy and wasn't too long. The movie, on the other hand, was boring in places.
|
|
Mart86
slytherin
BronzeCrimson37
Posts: 26
|
Post by Mart86 on Aug 16, 2011 17:22:15 GMT -5
Rate the 8 movies here.
PS - 6/10- Think I liked it more when I first saw it, but it was to wishy/washy for me lol CoS - 7/10 - Better than PS but preferred the soundtrack to the film I think PoA - 9/10 - My fave movie but deducted a point for the loss of the maurauders story GoF - 9/10 - Love this movie, great pace, so much darker OoTP - 5/10 - Least fave film and book, just seemed to slow, and Yates totally lost my faith when he directed this HBP - 7/10 - This movie has the same kind of pace as CoS, dunno why DH1 - 9/10 - Loved it, only wish they had kept in the entire flashback of James and Lily's murders, but it had great pace and got me on Yates side DH2 - 9/10 - Again, loved this film but wish they had shown more deaths the way they were meant to be seen, and have the battle between Harry and Voldemort in the great hall with everyone cheering and all the inhabitants of hogsmead running in to help, plus the fact that Hogwarts changed so much with the viaduct and the moving staircase...those really annoyed me lol. But Snapes memories and the ending more than made up for it.
|
|
TheChosenOne
Magical
SpiritSpell31 - Pottermore/SnivyCap - Chatango
Posts: 44
|
Post by TheChosenOne on Aug 24, 2011 23:11:13 GMT -5
ALright, let's give this my best.
PS/SS: 7.5/10 - Happy and bright, still interesting, a good movie in general. CoS: 5.5/10 - Could have been better, it was really slow, and boring in some parts. PoA: 8/10 - Better, werewolf scene is cool, all that jazz, but would have liked to seen more explanation on the whole Marauder's Map group thing, things like that. GoF: 8.5/10 - This is great, Voldemort is back and made a good entrance, (Except for the Pedobear reference) but the whole Neville vs. Dobby for Gillyweed is messing with me... Neville is the Herbology freak, so it makes sense, but I think Dobby would probably get the Gillyweed. Maybe teamwork involved? OoTP: 5/10 *Sighs* Details, details, details. Didn't the Director ever have Language Arts class? Details are very important! Would have been better, but too many missing details. HBP: 9/10 Freaking amazing. Sure, there's emo Draco, annoying Harry, and stuff like that, but it was still pretty much full with plot. Although, would have been better if they included the book version of hiding the book, because in DH it would make more sense, things like that. DH Part 1: 8.5/10 - Still amazing. Harry is not AS annoying, but just a hint or two of annoying sauce, but better. Prolonged camping trip is ok. DH Part 2: 9.5/10 Near perfection. Harry is back to good old PoA with MORE heroics, but it would have been better with the Great Hall fight instead of the boring old Priori Incantatem. Still, Molly's saying just made me make this 9.5. ;D
|
|